When our staff members are replying to staff applications, we ask for them to write not only about anything that has to do with the application, but their personal experiences. Convoy wrote about their personal experience they had with you the last time they saw you. I see this as less of a grudge and more that he was being truthful. Even so, we do not go off the ratings alone, we gather our senior mods, admins, and owners to take an additional look and create their own opinion. There have been times where people with majority -1’s have been accepted due to senior moderator majority for them. This is no reason to file a report, especially when no staff rules nor server rules were broken.